Historical, Philosophical, Political and Law Sciences, Culturology and Study of Art. Issues of Theory and Practice. Tambov: Gramota, 2017. № 6. Part 1. P. 18-22.
INTERPRETATION OF THE BASHKIRS’ HISTORY IN "MUSTAFAD AL-AKHBAR" BY ?IHABETDIN M?RCANI AND "TALFIK AL-AKHBAR" BY MURAD RAMZI: SOURCE BASE AND METHODOLOGICAL APPROACHES
Akhmadullin Salavat Zyamilovich
Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences in Moscow
Abstract. The article is devoted to historical works "Talfik al-akhbar" by Murad Ramzi and "Mustafad al-akhbar" by ?ihabetdin M?rcani. Creative heritage of M. Ramzi and ?. M?rcani is of great importance for understanding historical and cultural processes in the Ural-Volga region at the turn of the XIX-XX centuries and formation of national historiography of the Muslim peoples of the region. In order to reveal the degree of compilativity of the first work in relation to the second one, a comparative analysis of the section "The State of Affairs of the Bashkirs" from "Talfik al-akhbar" and "The Section on References to the Bashkirs" from "Mustafad al-akhbar" is carried out. It showed that differences in periodization, composition, source base, methods of working with sources and interpretation of history of the Bashkirs are a proof in favor of originality of "Talfik".
Key words and phrases: "Талфик ал-ахбар" Мурада Рамзи, "Мустафад ал-ахбар" Шихабутдина Марджани, история татар и башкир, мусульманские историки, "Talfik al-akhbar" by Murad Ramzi, "Mustafad al-akhbar" by ?ihabetdin M?rcani, history of the Tatars and the Bashkirs, Muslim historians
Open the whole article in PDF format. Free PDF-files viewer can be downloaded .
References:
Validi Z. T. Vospominaniya / per. s tur. A. Yuldashbaeva. Ufa: Kitap, 1998. 368 s.
Gordlevskii V. A. Izbrannye sochineniya: v 4-kh t. M., 1968. T. IV. 603 s.
Gubaidullin G. Razvitie istoricheskoi literatury u tyurko-tatarskikh narodov // Pervyi vsesoyuznyi tyurkologicheskii s"ezd (26 fevralya - 5 marta 1926 g.): stenograficheskii otchet. Baku, 1926. S. 22-43.
Zaitsev I. V. Krymskaya istoriograficheskaya traditsiya XV-XIX vekov: puti razvitiya: rukopisi, teksty i istochniki / In-t vostokovedeniya RAN. M.: Izd. firma "Vostochnaya literatura" RAN, 2009. 304 s.
Katanov N. F. Kratkii obzor' tatarskikh' istoricheskikh' knig'. Kazan': Tipo-litografiya Imperatorskago Universiteta, 1912. 4 s.
Kemper M. Sufii i uchenye v Tatarstane i Bashkortostane: islamskii diskurs pod russkim gospodstvom / per. s nem. I. Gilyazova. Kazan': Rossiiskii islamskii universitet, 2008. 655 s.
Mardzhani Sh. Mustafad al-akhbar fi akhvali Kazan va Bolgar: v 2-kh t. Kazan, 1897. T. 1. 264 b.; 1900. T. 2. 368 b.
Mekhdiev R. Abdulla khazrat Seiiid-Battal ugly Mullakai. Orenburg, 1916. 17 s.
Nauchnyi arkhiv Ufimskogo nauchnogo tsentra Rossiiskoi akademii nauk (NA UNTs RAN). F. 116. Lichnyi fond Railya Gumerovicha Kuzeeva. Op. 1.
Natsional'nyi arkhiv Respubliki Tatarstan (NART). F. 420. Op. 1.
Ramzi M. M. Talfik al-akhbar va talkikh al-asar fi vakai Kazan va Bulgar va muluk at-tatar: v 2-kh t. Orenburg, 1908. T. 1. 736 b.; T. 2. 539 b.
Salikhov R. R. Tatarskaya burzhuaziya Rossiiskoi imperii: vzaimodeistvie s obshchestvom i vlast'yu: vtoraya polovina XIX - nachalo XX v.: diss.. d.i.n. Kazan', 2006. 538 c.
Tyurkologicheskii sbornik / Ros. akad. nauk; S.-Peterb. fil. In-ta vostokovedeniya. M.: Vostochnaya literatura, 2002. 375 s.
Yuzeev A. N. Tatarskaya religiozno-reformatorskaya mysl' (XIX - nachalo XX v.). Kazan': Tatar. kn. izd-vo, 2012. 287 s.
Yusupov M. Kh. "Talfik al-akhbar va talkikh al-asar" M. Ramzi kak istochnik po istorii tyurkoyazychnykh narodov Povolzh'ya // Tezisy konferentsii aspirantov i molodykh sotrudnikov. M., 1978. T. 3. Ch. 2. S. 145-146.
Русский
