GRAMOTA Publishers suggests publishing your scientific articles in periodicals
Pan-ArtPedagogy. Theory & PracticePhilology. Theory & PracticeManuscript

Archive of Scientific Articles

SOURCE:    Manuscript. Tambov: Gramota, 2021. № 8. P. 1669-1678.
SCIENTIFIC AREA:    Philosophical Sciences
Procedure of Scientific Articles Publication | To Show Issue Content | To Show All Articles in Section | Subject Index

License Agreement on scientific materials use.

https://doi.org/10.30853/mns210273

Critical Realism in Dialogue between Science and Religion: I. Barbour and J. Polkinghorne’s Approach
Kiryanov Dmitry Viktorovich
Tobolsk Theological Seminary
Submitted: 28.06.2021
Abstract. The purpose of the study is to identify specific nature and characteristic features of critical realism methodology used by I. Barbour and J. Polkinghorne in elaboration of the problems peculiar to the dialogue between science and religion. The article presents an analysis of justification concerning the use of critical realism methodology in the dialogue between science and religion. Scientific novelty lies in the fact that the study reveals causes of the debate on using critical realism methodology in science and religion, shows limitations of applying critical realism in the field of religion, as well as identifies possible ways to adjust the considered authors’ approach to the dialogue between science and religion. As a result, it is proved that even though critical realism can serve as a "bridge" in the dialogue between scientific and religious worldviews, its use has significant limitations in the field of theology.
Key words and phrases: И. Барбур, Дж. Полкинхорн, критический реализм, эпистемология, онтология, наука и религия, философия науки, I. Barbour, J. Polkinghorne, critical realism, epistemology, ontology, science and religion, philosophy of science
Open the whole article in PDF format. Free PDF-files viewer can be downloaded here.
References:
  1. Barbur I. Religiya i nauka: istoriya i sovremennost'. M.: BBI, 2000. 430 s.
  2. Polkinkhorn Dzh. Vera glazami fizika. Bogoslovskie zametki myslitelya "snizu-vverkh". M.: BBI, 2000. 228 s.
  3. Barbour I. G. A Personal Odyssey // Theology and Science. 2017. Vol. 15. Issue 1. P. 5-16.
  4. Barbour I. G. Commentary on Theological Resources from the Physical Sciences // Zygon. 1966. Vol. 1. Issue 1. P. 27-30.
  5. Barbour I. G. Experiencing and Interpreting Nature in Science and Religion // Zygon. 1994. Vol. 29. Issue. 4. P. 457-487.
  6. Barbour I. G. Issues in Science and Religion. N. J.: Prentice Hall, 1966. 430 p.
  7. Barbour I. G. John Polkinghorne on Three Scientist-Theologians // God and the Scientist. Exploring the Work of John Polkinghorne / ed. by F. Watts, C. C. Knight. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing, 2012. P. 13-33.
  8. Barbour I. G. Myths, Models and Paradigms: A Comparative Study in Science and Religion. N. Y.: Harper & Row, 1976. 188 p.
  9. Barbour I. G. On Typologies for Relating Science and Religion // Zygon. 2002. Vol. 37. Issue 2. P. 345-360.
  10. Barbour I. G. Response to Critiques of Religion in an Age of Science // Zygon. 1996. Vol. 31. Issue 1. P. 51-65.
  11. Barbour I. G. Taking Science Seriously without Scientism: A Response to Taede Smedes // Zygon. 2008. Vol. 43. Issue 1. P. 259-269.
  12. Bennett P. Subtle and Supple: John Polkinghorne’s Engagement with Reality // God and the Scientist. Exploring the Work of John Polkinghorne / ed. by F. Watts, C. C. Knight. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing, 2012. P. 175-197.
  13. Berg Ch. Theologie im technischen Zeitalter. Das Werk Ian Barbours als Beitrag zur Verh?ltnisbestimmung von Theologie zu Naturwissenschaft und Technik. Stuttgart: Kohlhammer Verlag, 2002. 352 S.
  14. Buitendag J. "Epistemology models ontology" - In gesprek met John Polkinghorne // HTS Theological Studies. 2011. Vol. 67. № 1. P. 1-9.
  15. Cartwright N., Martin E. Queen Physics: How Much of the Globe Is Painted Red? // God and the Scientist. Exploring the Work of John Polkinghorne / ed. by F. Watts, C. C. Knight. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing, 2012. P. 67-77.
  16. Dicken P. A Critical Introduction to Scientific Realism. L.: Bloomsbury, 2016. 224 p.
  17. Dinter A. Vom Glauben eines Physikers. John Polkinghornes Beitrag zum Dialog zwischen Theologie und Naturwissenschaften. Mainz: Matthias-Gr?newald-Verlag, 1999. 184 S.
  18. Drees W. B. Religion, Science and Naturalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996. 314 p.
  19. Huyssteen J. W. van. Theology and the Justification of Faith. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989. 226 p.
  20. Jackson J. D. Rochester Roundabout: The Story of High Energy Physics // Physics Today. 1990. Vol. 43. № 11. P. 87-88.
  21. Knight Ch. Science and Christian Faith. A Guide for Perplexed. N. Y.: St. Vladimir Seminary Press, 2020. 232 p.
  22. Losch A. Appreciating Faith and Culture in an Age of Scientific Reasoning: On Constructive-Critical Realism // Theology Today. 2018. Vol. 75. Issue 2. P. 154-166.
  23. Losch A. Critical Realism - A Sustainable Bridge between Science and Religion? // Theology and Science. 2010. Vol. 8. Issue 4. P. 393-416.
  24. Losch A. On the Origins of Critical Realism // Theology and Science. 2009. Vol. 7. Issue 1. P. 85-106.
  25. Losch A. Our world is more than physics: A constructive-critical comment on the current science and theology debate // Theology and Science. 2005. Vol. 3. Issue 3. P. 275-290.
  26. McMullin E. A Case for Scientific Realism // Scientific Realism / ed. by J. Leplin. Berkley: University of California Press, 1984. P. 8-40.
  27. McMullin E. Realism in Theology and Science: A Response to Peacocke // Religion and Intellectual Life. 1985. Vol. 2. Issue 4. P. 39-47.
  28. Murphy N. From Critical Realism to a Methodological Approach: Response to Robbins, Van Huyssteen, and Hefner // Zygon. 1988. Vol. 23. Issue 3. P. 287-290.
  29. Murphy N. Religion, Theology, and the Philosophy of Science: An Appreciation of the Work of Ian Barbour // Theology and Science. 2017. Vol. 15. Issue 1. P. 42-52.
  30. Murphy N. Theology and Science within Lakatoshian Program // Zygon. 1999. Vol. 34. Issue 4. P. 629-642.
  31. Polkinghorne J. C. Belief in God in an Age of Science. Terry Lectures. Yale: Yale University Press, 1998. 132 p.
  32. Polkinghorne J. C. Beyond Science. The Wider Human Context. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996. 130 p.
  33. Polkinghorne J. C. Exploring Reality. The Intertwining of Science and Religion. Yale: Yale University Press, 2005. 181 p.
  34. Polkinghorne J. C. From Physicist to Priest. An Autobiography. L.: SPCK, 2007. 182 p.
  35. Polkinghorne J. C. One World. The Interaction of Science and Theology. L.: Templeton Foundation Press, 2007. 131 p.
  36. Polkinghorne J. C. Quantum Physics and Theology. An Unexpected Kinship. Yale: Yale University Press, 2007. 112 p.
  37. Polkinghorne J. C. Quantum Theory. A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. 113 p.
  38. Polkinghorne J. C. Quarks, Chaos and Christianity. L.: SPCK, 2005. 128 p.
  39. Polkinghorne J. C. Reason and Reality. L.: SPCK, 1991. 118 p.
  40. Polkinghorne J. C. Science and Providence. L.: Templeton Foundation Press, 2005. 128 p.
  41. Polkinghorne J. C. Science and Trinity. The Christian Encounter with Reality. Yale: Yale University Press, 2004. 184 p.
  42. Polkinghorne J. C. Scientists as Theologians: A Comparison of the Writings of Ian Barbour, Arthur Peacocke and John Polkinghorne. L.: SPCK, 1996. 96 p.
  43. Polkinghorne J. C. Serious Talk. L.: SPCK, 1995. 117 p.
  44. Russell R. J. Assessing Ian G. Barbour’s Contributions to Theology and Science // Theology and Science. 2017. Vol. 15. Issue 1. P. 1-4.
  45. Russell R. J. Ian Barbour’s Methodological Breakthrough: Creating the "Bridge" between Science and Theology // Theology and Science. 2017. Vol. 15. Issue 1. P. 28-41.
  46. Saeter K. W. Traces of God. Exploring John Polkinghorne on Theology and Science. Trondheim: Tapir Academic Press, 2011. 248 p.
  47. Smedes T. Beyond Barbour or Back to Basics? The Future of Science-and-Religion and the Quest for Unity // Zygon. 2008. Vol. 43. Issue 1. P. 253-254.
  48. Steinke J. M. John Polkinghorne. Konsonanz von Naturwissenschaft und Theologie. G?ttingen: Vandenhoek & Ruprecht, 2006. 132 S.
  49. Torrance T. F. Theological Science. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1969. 368 p.
  50. Welker M. Processes of Discovery in Science and Theology: Bottom-up Approach, Critical Realism and Interdisciplinary Inspiration // God and the Scientist. Exploring the Work of John Polkinghorne / ed. by F. Watts, C. C. Knight. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing, 2012. P. 257-267.
  51. Wright A. Christianity and Critical Realism. Ambiguity, Truth and Theological Literacy. L.: Routledge, 2013. 332 p.
  52. York C. M. Ian Barbour’s Contributions as a Scientist // Theology and Science. 2017. Vol. 15. Issue 1. P. 17-27.
Procedure of Scientific Articles Publication | To Show Issue Content | To Show All Articles in Section | Subject Index

© 2006-2024 GRAMOTA Publishers

site development and search engine optimization (seo): krav.ru