GRAMOTA Publishers suggests publishing your scientific articles in periodicals
Pan-ArtPedagogy. Theory & PracticePhilology. Theory & PracticeManuscript

Archive of Scientific Articles

SOURCE:    Philology. Theory & Practice. Tambov: Gramota, 2019. № 11. P. 335-342.
SCIENTIFIC AREA:    Philological Sciences
Procedure of Scientific Articles Publication | To Show Issue Content | To Show All Articles in Section | Subject Index

License Agreement on scientific materials use.

https://doi.org/10.30853/filnauki.2019.11.71

LINGUISTIC-ARGUMENTATIVE ANALYSIS OF CRITICISM IN SCIENTIFIC EXPERTISE (BY THE MATERIAL OF REVIEWS OF RESEARCH PAPERS ON LINGUISTICS)
Barebina Natal'ya Sergeevna, Zyryanova Irina Nikolaevna
Baikal State University
Submitted: 15.08.2019
Abstract. The article is devoted to analysing criticism in reviews of research papers on linguistics. The study aims to identify models and samples of scientific criticism presentation by means of linguistic-argumentative analysis. A review structure is analysed using the model of critical discussion within the framework of the pragma-dialectical method. All the examples are classified using the model of critical perception focused on rebuttal. The proposed classification allows the authors to identify the most frequent points of criticism in the scientific review format.
Key words and phrases: критика, проаргументация, контраргументация, наука, научная экспертиза, рецензия, criticism, pro-argumentation, counter-argumentation, science, scientific expertise, review
Open the whole article in PDF format. Free PDF-files viewer can be downloaded here.
References:
  1. Barebina N. S. Vvedenie v teoriyu argumentatsii dlya spetsial'nostei "Lingvistika", "Perevod i perevodovedenie": ucheb. posobie / pod nauch. red. G. M. Kostyushkinoi. Irkutsk: Izd-vo BGU, 2018. 138 s.
  2. Barebina N. S. Vidy otritsatel'nykh umozaklyuchenii v argumentativnykh dialogakh // Problemy kontseptual'noi sistematiki rechi i rechevoi deyatel'nosti: materialy 9-i Vseros. nauch. konf. / pod red. G. M. Kostyushkinoi. Irkutsk: Izd-vo IGLU, 2015. C. 64-71.
  3. Belov A. M. J. Clackson. Indo-European linguistics. An introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007. 260 p.: rets. na kn. // Voprosy yazykoznaniya. 2010. № 2. S. 123-128.
  4. Borisova E. G. Slovar'-tezaurus sovremennoi russkoi idiomatiki / pod red. A. N. Baranova, D. O. Dobrovol'skogo (avtory A. N. Baranov, D. O. Dobrovol'skii, K. L. Kiseleva, A. D. Kozerenko; pri uchastii M. M. Voznesenskoi i M. M. Korobovoi). M.: Mir entsiklopedii. Avanta +, 2007. 1135 s.: rets. na kn. // Voprosy yazykoznaniya. 2010. № 1. S. 120-122.
  5. Grinenko G. V. Argumentatsiya: opyt germenevticheskogo analiza // Mysl': zhurnal Peterburgskogo filosofskogo obshchestva. 2006. T. 6. № 1. S. 48-63.
  6. Derbisheva Z. K. Retsenziya na knigu: Edinstvo Evropy po dannym leksiki // Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Filologiya. 2018. № 54. S. 26-266.
  7. Katermina V. V. Vstupitel'naya stat'ya // Kognitivno-diskursivnye issledovaniya v yazyke i rechi: monografiya / pod red. V. V. Katerminoi. Krasnodar: Kubanskii gos. un-t, 2017. S. 3-6.
  8. Katyshev P. A. Oblagorazhivayushchii vkus metafor. Retsenziya na knigu: Yurina E. A. Vkusnye metafory: pishchevaya traditsiya v zerkale yazykovykh obrazov. Kokchetav: Keleshek, 2013. 238 s. // Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Filologiya. 2015. № 4 (36). S. 190-198.
  9. Kornilova G. I., Bamenov A. A. Argumentatsiya kak kommunikativnoe deistvie. Irkutsk: Izd-vo IrGTU, 2006. 138 s.
  10. Korchagin K. M. N. Fabb, M. Halle. Meter in poetry. A new theory. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2008. 309 p.: rets. na kn. // Voprosy yazykoznaniya. 2010. № 1. S. 138-146.
  11. Kostyushkina G. M. Argumentatsiya i kontseptual'naya sistematika rechi i rechevoi deyatel'nosti // Kontseptual'naya sistematika argumentatsii: kollektivnaya monografiya / nauch. red. G. M. Kostyushkina. M.: Flinta; Nauka, 2016. S. 10-69.
  12. Merton R. K. Sotsial'naya teoriya i sotsial'naya struktura / per. s angl. E. N. Egorovoi i dr.; nauch. red. Z. V. Koganova. M.: AST; Khranitel', 2006. 873 s.
  13. Minor S. A. W. D. Davies, S. Dubinsky (eds.). New horizons in the analysis of control and raising. Dordrecht: Springer, 2007. X+354 p.: rets. na kn. // Voprosy yazykoznaniya. 2010. № 3. S. 115-126.
  14. Nesheva T. V. Kommunikativno-pragmaticheskii potentsial slov-argumentatorov // Kontseptual'naya sistematika argumentatsii: kollektivnaya monografiya / nauch. red. G. M. Kostyushkina. M.: Flinta; Nauka, 2016. S. 390-481.
  15. Oshchepkova N. A. Yazykovye sredstva opisaniya argumentativnosti // Uchenye zapiski Orlovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya "Gumanitarnye i sotsial'nye nauki". 2011. № 6 (44). S. 228-233.
  16. Potanina N. L. Retsenziya na monografiyu O. V. Lebedevoi "Angliiskaya novella: istoriya i sovremennost'" (Velikii Novgorod: Izd-vo NovGu im. Yaroslava Mudrogo, 2016. 158 s.) // Neofilologiya. 2018. T. 4. № 13. S. 71-75.
  17. Puchkova E. V. Argumentativno-lingvisticheskii analiz diskursa oproverzheniya: diss. … k. filol. n. Kaluga, 2006. 203 s.
  18. Sitosanova O. V. Semantika i pragmatika slov-argumentatorov v bytovom diskurse // Kontseptual'naya sistematika argumentatsii: kollektivnaya monografiya / nauch. red. G. M. Kostyushkina. M.: Flinta; Nauka, 2016. S. 482-538.
  19. Fanyan N. Yu. Argumentatsiya kak lingvopragmaticheskaya struktura: diss. … d. filol. n. Krasnodar, 2000. 354 s.
  20. Chernyavskaya V. E. Nauchno-issledovatel'skaya stat'ya kak verbalizatsiya novogo nauchnogo rezul'tata (na materiale lingvistiki) // Zhanry rechi. 2016. № 1 (13). S. 56-64.
  21. Etos nauki / otv. red. L. P. Kiyashchenko, E. Z. Mirskaya. M.: Akademiya, 2008. 535 s.
  22. Anscombre J.-C., Ducrot O. L`argumentation dans la langue. Bruxelles: Magrada, 1983. 184 r.
  23. Finocchiaro M. Arguments about Arguments: Systematic, Critical, and Historical Essays in Logical Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005. 467 p.
  24. Fortin C. R. Review of Searching for Structure [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: https://linguistlist.org/pubs/reviews/get-review.cfm?SubID=15189 (data obrashcheniya: 01.10.2019).
  25. Julich N. Review of Studies in Figurative Thought and Language [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: https://linguistlist. org/pubs/reviews/get-review.cfm?SubID=36366937 (data obrashcheniya: 01.10.2019).
  26. Krabbe E. C. W., Laar J. A. van. The Ways of Criticism // Argumentation. 2011. № 25 (2). P. 199-227.
  27. Larsson T. Review of New Challenges for Language Testing [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: https://linguistlist.org/pubs/ reviews/get-review.cfm?SubID=36294837 (data obrashcheniya: 01.10.2019).
  28. Slotta J. Review of Culture and Language Use [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: https://linguistlist.org/pubs/reviews/get-review.cfm?SubID=2637714 (data obrashcheniya: 01.10.2019).
Procedure of Scientific Articles Publication | To Show Issue Content | To Show All Articles in Section | Subject Index

© 2006-2024 GRAMOTA Publishers

site development and search engine optimization (seo): krav.ru